An early favorite to win the competition, she faltered in later appearances and was voted out one week after a "tone-deaf" performance of The Kinks classic "You Really Got Me". Simon called her out on this, calling it "dreadful". She dismissed it, calling him a "popper" instead of a "rocker". His response was, "I like rock music when it's sung in tune".

Shortly after her run on American Idol, Starr made a guest appearance on the popular FOX network comedy That '70s Show, leading to brief and unsubstantiated rumors that FOX would develop a show to capitalize on her popularity with young males. In 2004, she starred in the third season of the reality show The Surreal Life on VH1.

She is said to be pursuing her goal of marketing a line of clothing fashioned after the ripped and torn garments she sported on American Idol.

Musician, Reality TV, Television Personalities, Entertainers, Performances, Live performances, Actors, Celebrity Broadcasting, Journalism, Acting, Music,